User Review Real or Fake ? - Xiaomi 10400 mAh Power Bank

Hey guys,
Firstly to the mods, please move this to the appropriate section. I'm not sure where this one belongs.
Why this thread has gone up is because I recently got 2 Xiaomi 10400mAh Power Banks (XPB for short) from Ebay from the seller AllPhoneUnlock: http://stores.ebay.in/allphoneunlock/
The 1st one is the white model, which I procured from http://www.ebay.in/itm/271499716397?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649 for 1100 bucks (using Axis coupon; was listed for 1299).
The 2nd one is a golden one (as the white went was going for crazy prices) from here http://www.ebay.in/itm/281357022775?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649 (1300 bucks; same coupon; listed for 1499)
Got the 1st one around a week back and have been using it since. Works wonderfully. The 2nd one came 2 days back and just looking at the packing made me suspicious.
I looked at http://en.miui.com/thread-19104-1-1.html (pointers for figure real vs fake XPBs) and found the following differences (which warrant me to believe that the 2nd one is fake):
(P.S.: Before beginning, BOTH the packing came with Xiaomi stickers, which when scratched, revealed a code, which when checked on the Xiaomi verification website, said BOTH are genuine. However, I'm not convinced, so let's see the following points)
1) Packing: The 1st one i.e. the white/silver XPB came in a SEALED satin-ish paper, which had to be peeled away to reveal the PB. There was no way one could take out the PB without damaging the packing. Again, it was sealed. Moreover, the PB was then sealed inside another white plastic box. So double sealing. And exemplary packing.
The 2nd one i.e. golden XPB came in a cardboard box, UNSEALED. Huge difference in packing. One could just open the box and replace whatever was inside. No seals, no plastic box, nothing. Very strange.
2) Lights/LEDs: Please look at the picture below:
hArNLUq.jpg

If you notice carefully, the golden one has DARKER LEDs when compared to the white one. There seems to be some translucent covering behind the white one to minimize overglow.
Moreover, when we press the button to see the charging status, things become more clear:
1iUnzJx.jpg

The golden one has light bleeding, whereas
EerxCll.jpg

The white ones doesn't !
3) Ports/Paint:
8bc9MVn.jpg

As you can see, the golden PB's micro-USB port is NOT CENTERED, whereas the white one is perfectly centered in the casing (I'm not sure how far the pic can show this, but holding both the PB at eye level show this). Moreover, the golden one's PAINTJOB is CHIPPED at couple of places as marked. The white one is flawless all around.
4) Printing: Another pic:
ffGqvFH.jpg

If you see closely, you'll notice that the golden one has a darker printing as compared to the smoother one on the white PB.
Another pic to show the same:
APXEhPY.jpg


What do you guys think ? Can you compare your XPBs with the posted pics and see any similarities/differences ? Please chip in. Meanwhile, I'll try to have a word with the seller.[DOUBLEPOST=1406671086][/DOUBLEPOST]Oh, and the reason I'm putting it up (was asked on another forum as how does it matter, sab chinese hain), the difference is mucho. Xiaomi uses LG batteries and Texas Instruments chip to control power on board, making it safer. The cheaper ones using thin wiring and unverified chips which can cause explosions. Check here: http://en.miui.com/thread-19104-1-1.html
Can cause major fire hazard.

@Spacescreamer @piper[DOUBLEPOST=1406674365][/DOUBLEPOST]Just went through this video:
Looks like what I've is genuine. The usb cable is of the right color (and without logo as well). I haven't checked pass through charging. Will do it sometime later.
 
Last edited:
I have bought 5 of these power banks for myself and friends from the same seller as listed in the previous page.
3 were in hard plastic boxes and 2 that i ordered a couple of days back were in white cardboard boxes only.

The mild scratches if any are because of the dust that gets in to these cardboard boxes.

All units have been tested using the reference video by OP and they all check out.

This seller is indeed genuine and you can order from him without any worries.
 
Ya the shipping is super fast.
Bought at 2pm yesterday. shipped at 3pm. its in Bangalore as of now.havent got it in my hand though[DOUBLEPOST=1407411598][/DOUBLEPOST]I got mine now.
An update - Initially the LED's on one of the powerbank was flickering.However it disappeared when i put it up for charge and its blinking solidly now.
Also when i keep the power button pressed when the powerbank is getting charged, none of the led's light up.
Also is it difficult to insert the usb cable for charginf the mobile into the slot in the powerbank??
I dont know why but i feel i got a fake one.
 
Last edited:
sure.
One more updates is that i charged one of the powerbank.all the LED's were blinking even after 8 hrs.
However it is not charging when i connect my phone to it.its dead i suppose.

Also wanted to confirm if the power bank starts charging the phone as soon as we connect the phone to it ie we dont need to press the power button to switch it on?? If so then what is the use of the power button??

Can anybody post the link of miui website where in i can check the authenticity of the power bank by entering the serial number??

Also can someone let me know what is charging pass method of checking the authenticity as i cannot access the video .
 
sure.
One more updates is that i charged one of the powerbank.all the LED's were blinking even after 8 hrs.
However it is not charging when i connect my phone to it.its dead i suppose.

Also wanted to confirm if the power bank starts charging the phone as soon as we connect the phone to it ie we dont need to press the power button to switch it on?? If so then what is the use of the power button??

Can anybody post the link of miui website where in i can check the authenticity of the power bank by entering the serial number??

Also can someone let me know what is charging pass method of checking the authenticity as i cannot access the video .
Check here: http://order.mi.com/service/dyscode
1) It should charge as soon as it is connected. If you need to the button to charge, it is fake.
2) Button is used to check the capacity (and in some ways to identify b/w real and fake)
3) Pass through charging: Connect the XPB to mains and mobile at the same time. If the mobile is getting charged, pass through works.
Looks life you got a fake/dead product. Contact the seller.
 
1) Yes it is charging as soon as i connect the mobile to it.
2) Ya when i hold the button it shows the capacity.however whenever i hold the button,all the LED's vanish.
3)Pass through charging works.Also when i connect the dead one to charge and connect the mobile to it,pass thorough charging works.(ie the dead one can charge when its getting charge.But what's the point of having a portable charger if it cant charge the phone in a stand alone condition :p)
And the LED flickering has vanished now.

Now I am in a confused state whether to return both the ones or only the one that is dead.
 
At least return the dead one. And if you're the adventurous type, open the other one and check for LG batteries and Texas Instrument's control chipset. :p
 
Well that is a go0d suggestion :)

But the flickering LED's are worrying me even though they are are intermittent

And ya both the codes on the boxes qualified as original.
 
Well that is a go0d suggestion :)

But the flickering LED's are worrying me even though they are are intermittent

And ya both the codes on the boxes qualified as original.
During charging the PB or charging the phones, LEDs will flicker to show the power remaining. Normal stuff.
 
Well i checked both the codes and they qualified as original.

However what if the code is original and the product inside has been replaced by a duplicate one??

@alekhkhanna
The LED's flicked which charging the PB.


But does pressing and holding the power switches switch of all the LED's??
Pressing the power button shows the power remaining though.
 
^^ Yeah. Holding the power button will only keep the lights on when you're charging the power bank (else just flickering to show the remaining power). Try it out !
 
Nope .the LED's don switch on even when he PB is getting charged and the power button is pressed and held.[DOUBLEPOST=1407551315][/DOUBLEPOST]An update on the working PB. I charged it for more than 8 hrs using a 2A wall charger. And after 8 hrs when i pressed the power button to check the amount of charge available, all the 4 led's came on and then vanished one by one except for the last led.Now when i connect my phone to the PB ,only the last LED is blinking.
Is this normal??
 
Last edited:
getting very confused signals about the product from this thread! would it not be better to wait for the flipkart stocks to be available again, and be assured of the product authenticity? or am i missing something here?
 
The seller had called me yesterday.Seems to be a genuine person.He has an office in China too it seems.He asked me to check the product again and if it doesnt work then he is ready to send a replacement.Looks genuine since the code worked.Maybe i got a defective product.
 
Back
Top