TechEnclave
New Tech Posts
New Market Posts
TechEnclave RuleBook



Comment
 
LinkBack (4) Review Tools
<!-- google_ad_section_start -->LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage<!-- google_ad_section_end -->
LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage
Published by apollyon
12 Nov 09
Member rating
Rate This Review
53.6%53.6%53.6%
2.68
25 users rated 54% average
Default Introduction

Ever since overclocking has started gaining popularity, the demand for better cooling, be it air or water has started increasing. CPU makers have always provided stock coolers which would barely manage to keep the CPU at acceptable temperatures at stock speed but thats about it. This meant that there was very little room left for one to overclock even if he could, since the cooler just couldn't manage to keep the temperatures under control.
Due to price constraints and of course to dissuade people from over clocking, CPU makers have always bundled mediocre coolers with their CPU's. This is where third party air cooler makers come into the picture. Although a bit expensive, they are pretty much worth the extra money you pay.
Depending on the application there are several different models available. There are some which are light in weight, yet much more efficient than stock coolers and which also allow you some mild overclocking.
Then there are those which are huge and heavy but are very efficient when it comes to keeping temperatures under control even with very high overclocks.

Today we have with us here 3 different coolers, couple of fans, thermal pastes to test. Basically, all the basic ingredients that you need for starting your overclocking endeavors.

Today we will be testing the Cogage True Spirit, Noctua NH-U12P SE2 and our old workhorse, the Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme.
Please bear in mind that all these 3 coolers cater to different segments.

Now that you are aware of what we would be doing today, let’s get on with it, without wasting much time

Note - Review is very picture heavy, 56K users are warned

Published by
apollyon's Avatar
Birdy Num Num
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Pune
Posts: 1,780
apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great apollyon is just Great

Contents

Review Tools

| More



  4 links from elsewhere to this Post. Click to view. #1 (permalink)  
By WingZero on 12 Nov 09, 04:13 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Nice review appo. dugged, cudn't rep need to spread.
what about pricing?..
Last edited by WingZero; 12 Nov 09 at 04:18 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
By apollyon on 12 Nov 09, 04:19 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

thanks joint effort, me and amey
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
By mav2000 on 12 Nov 09, 04:27 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Very very very very good review...excellent made for a great read on this boring afternoon.

I want to get my hands on the idiot who rated this as 0.......

Anyway reps to you and great work...really enjoyed it.

The Noctua is made to work with low cfm/noise fans, specially with the way the fins are spaced out. It would be interesting to see the difference in results if the noctua was used with its own fans in push/pull and a set of high cfm fans in push/pull, at the same OC.

Also what were ure ambients and were u using only software system temps, or was any hardware measuring also done?

Am very happy to see the AMD part of the review, perhaps it can be added to the title?
Last edited by mav2000; 12 Nov 09 at 04:32 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
By The Sorcerer on 12 Nov 09, 05:21 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Noctua is a great cooler indeed. Although they should bundled their own am2+ metal backplate for it.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
By apollyon on 12 Nov 09, 05:30 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

@mav, ambients were 28C, mentioned on the test setup page. Coretemp and realtemp were used, no way to measure using hw equipment
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
By thebanik on 12 Nov 09, 05:35 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

would have been nice to see TRUE rev C added to the mix as well, but nonetheless good review.....
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
By BIKeINSTEIN on 12 Nov 09, 07:19 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Very nice.

One thing i noticed is-
The heatpipes in the COGAGE are full and rounded where they exit the base and space around it filled with solder, like the AC coolers, eg freezer 64 pro, freezer 7 pro, etc.
The TR Ultra 120 (4-pipes, first model) had full rounded pipes but never seen so much solder, if they are soldered to the base to begin with.
Later generations, esp TRUE had the pipes somewhat flattened near the point of exit and not in contact with the base at the edges or even deeper at times, something i strongly disliked as i felt that could have affected performance a bit.
Last edited by BIKeINSTEIN; 13 Nov 09 at 01:18 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
By sarang on 13 Nov 09, 12:57 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Excellent review Appo (And Amey ).

Did I miss the prices mentioned here?
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
By |Anish| on 13 Nov 09, 05:03 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Superb review Appo and Amey!
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
By Alias on 13 Nov 09, 08:02 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Great effort and great review!

Suggestions? Please update prices and source of purchase.
Reply With Quote
  #11 (permalink)  
By apollyon on 13 Nov 09, 08:31 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Cogage True spirit will be soon available, no indicative pricing as of now. but it will be cheap thats for sure. pm KMD for a quote on the Noctua
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
By Sudarshan_SMD on 13 Nov 09, 10:24 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

nice review.

Am I reading it right? when overclocked TRUE performs better than other two coolers and when at stock other two coolers perform better than TRUE?
Reply With Quote
  #13 (permalink)  
By Amey on 13 Nov 09, 10:26 AM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Yes but you missed a small thing, TRUE + 2 high CFM 120mm fans in Push-Pull config.
Reply With Quote
  #14 (permalink)  
By |Anish| on 13 Nov 09, 05:03 PM
Default Re: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage

Guess what, prime has it and boy the price looks amazing !

CPU Cooler for the Intel 1366 Socket

Really not bad @ Rs.2250/- for the Cogage !
Last edited by |Anish|; 13 Nov 09 at 05:04 PM..
Reply With Quote
Comment

Tags
cogage , heatsink , lga1366 , noctua , true spirit


Review Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


LinkBacks (?)
LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.techenclave.com/reviews-and-previews/lga-1366-hsfs-reviewed-noctua-vs-151313.html
Posted By For Type Date
Who dugg: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage - TechEnclave This thread Refback 30 Nov 09 07:45 AM
LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage - TechEnclave This thread Refback 13 Nov 09 01:21 PM
Dry Technology: LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage This thread Refback 13 Nov 09 12:12 PM
LGA 1366 HSF's reviewed: Noctua Vs Cogage - TechEnclave This thread Refback 12 Nov 09 04:07 PM

Search TechEnclave
Register on TechEnclave to Remove the ads and the sidebar
Have some Fun!


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2