TechEnclave
Register Now

Registration is free.
Join us today.

What to do about throttling by an ISP?

This is a discussion on What to do about throttling by an ISP? within the P2P forums, part of the Software Zone category; Now its a well known fact that ISP like Airtel,BSNL etc are throttling Bittorrent traffic. Right now i am ...

TechEnclave > Software Zone > P2P


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1   Gaurish's Rig  
Old 14 May 08, 03:25 AM
Gaurish's Avatar
Explosive Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Jaipur
Posts: 1,395
Gaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly Admirable
Send a message via AIM to Gaurish Send a message via Yahoo to Gaurish
Unhappy What to do about throttling by an ISP?

Now its a well known fact that ISP like Airtel,BSNL etc are throttling Bittorrent traffic.


Right now i am downloading a Linux Distro from a well seeded torrent.
90seeds and 5leachers.
Availability: 62.993
Seeder to leacher ratio:18


so i am sure i can get max of it but i only get around 193kBps.
whereas in http download i easily reach 217kBp to 222kBps.
so i am not getting my full speed here.
i also have Encryption enabled.


ISP: BSNL Broadband
Plan: Home 500


So What to do about throttling by an ISP?


Last edited by Gaurish : 14 May 08 at 03:50 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 14 May 08, 02:06 PM
virtua_pirate's Avatar
Fanatic Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: neighbours house
Age: 21
Posts: 286
virtua_pirate is Mysterious
Send a message via MSN to virtua_pirate Send a message via Yahoo to virtua_pirate Send Message via Google Talk to virtua_pirate
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

i dont think BSNL throttles bittorrent traffic...besides, in torrents you'll always get speeds lower as compared to the http counterpart...agreed there are 90 seeds, but to how many seeds are you connected...??? the max i get on private trackers is 210kBps else it lingers around 185 to 195 for heavily seeded torrents...
try out a torrent from private tracker...

Reply With Quote
  #3   4dh1r's Rig  
Old 14 May 08, 04:29 PM
4dh1r's Avatar
Steroids Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Mumbai
Age: 26
Posts: 395
4dh1r is Notable4dh1r is Notable
Cool Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

Try to patch tcpip.sys to increase the maximum simultaneous half-open (incomplete) outbound TCP connection attempts per second that the system can make (if u r using Windows) and see if you get more seeds...

More details here:
Windows Vista tcpip.sys Connection Limit Patch for Event ID 4226

Ignore if u already did that (or if u r using Linux )

Reply With Quote
  #4   stellarhopper's Rig  
Old 14 May 08, 05:10 PM
stellarhopper's Avatar
Steroids Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Mumbai
Age: 21
Posts: 337
stellarhopper is somewhat of a mystery
Send a message via MSN to stellarhopper Send a message via Yahoo to stellarhopper Send Message via Google Talk to stellarhopper
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

is there anything like peerguardian for vista....
that might help

Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 14 May 08, 05:44 PM
virtua_pirate's Avatar
Fanatic Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: neighbours house
Age: 21
Posts: 286
virtua_pirate is Mysterious
Send a message via MSN to virtua_pirate Send a message via Yahoo to virtua_pirate Send Message via Google Talk to virtua_pirate
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

^^^ peer-guardian is just an ip filter...it wont speed up your torrents...
the patch posted by 4dhir will help though...apply that patch and increase the "net.max_halfopen" in your utorrent to "50"...


Last edited by virtua_pirate : 14 May 08 at 05:49 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #6   Anish's Rig  
Old 14 May 08, 06:01 PM
Anish's Avatar
Member of mass destruction
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Goa, India
Age: 19
Posts: 6,984
Toscars: 1
Anish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely EminentAnish is extremely Eminent
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

@ Gaurish - No reason to worry, most of my downloads on well seeded private trackers max out at 200KBps while HTTP downloads hover around 250KBps on an average.

I'm sure if you have 2 or more torrents running, your net B/W will be around 260-270KBps. If that isn't the case then your ISP is throttling traffic.

Reply With Quote
  #7   Gaurish's Rig  
Old 14 May 08, 11:07 PM
Gaurish's Avatar
Explosive Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Jaipur
Posts: 1,395
Gaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly Admirable
Send a message via AIM to Gaurish Send a message via Yahoo to Gaurish
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

Source - http://torrentfreak.com//images/vuze...in-results.pdf
All the major Indian ISPs - BSNL, VSNL, Reliance, Airtel are in that list.

Reply With Quote
  #8   greenhorn's Rig  
Old 15 May 08, 01:27 PM
greenhorn's Avatar
Nuclear Member
Member of the Month for March2008
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Thiruvanthoram
Age: 24
Posts: 4,401
Toscars: 2
greenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminentgreenhorn is extremely Eminent
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

PC World - Elude your ISP's BitTorrent blockade

Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 15 May 08, 03:10 PM
saumilsingh's Avatar
Explosive Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 2,292
Toscars: 1
saumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renownedsaumilsingh is extremely Renowned
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

BSNL doesn't throttle torrents.
If you are getting 'only' 200k instead of 217k, rest assured you aren't being throttled


Last edited by saumilsingh : 15 May 08 at 03:11 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #10   ComradE_BeaN's Rig  
Old 15 May 08, 03:19 PM
ComradE_BeaN's Avatar
Explosive Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: 59.32.*.*
Posts: 2,617
ComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly AdmirableComradE_BeaN is highly Admirable
Send a message via MSN to ComradE_BeaN Send a message via Yahoo to ComradE_BeaN
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

View Post
Originally Posted by Gaurish
Source - http://torrentfreak.com//images/vuze...in-results.pdf
All the major Indian ISPs - BSNL, VSNL, Reliance, Airtel are in that list.
link not opening

Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 15 May 08, 04:07 PM
Fanatic Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 162
true_power is Mysterious
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

View Post
Originally Posted by saumilsingh
BSNL doesn't throttle torrents.
If you are getting 'only' 200k instead of 217k, rest assured you aren't being throttled
I agree, in my experience BSNL doesn't throttle torrents, yes there are times their servers are dead slow or DNS poisoning happens. In such cases even the browsing doesn't work.

Reply With Quote
  #12   cisco_tech's Rig  
Old 15 May 08, 04:58 PM
cisco_tech's Avatar
Steroids Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Ahmedabad
Posts: 370
cisco_tech is very Respectablecisco_tech is very Respectablecisco_tech is very Respectable
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

Since BSNL has changed my DSL Profile to 5 Megz downstream and 1 Megz Upstream. I am getting between 250-300 KB.
On old profile 2048/256 . i was max. getting 200-205 KB.
Uploading is still capped at 16 KB though.
BSNL doesn't throttle for sure.

Reply With Quote
  #13   Gaurish's Rig  
Old 15 May 08, 10:19 PM
Gaurish's Avatar
Explosive Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Jaipur
Posts: 1,395
Gaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly AdmirableGaurish is highly Admirable
Send a message via AIM to Gaurish Send a message via Yahoo to Gaurish
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

how you guys are so sure?
any reason or thoery behind it?
why speeds are always less then what i get in torrents?


@ComradE_BeaN
try this --> http://digit.wsnw.net/uploads/pr11april08no34.pdf

Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 15 May 08, 11:21 PM
virtua_pirate's Avatar
Fanatic Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: neighbours house
Age: 21
Posts: 286
virtua_pirate is Mysterious
Send a message via MSN to virtua_pirate Send a message via Yahoo to virtua_pirate Send Message via Google Talk to virtua_pirate
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

why would they throttle the bandwidth by mere 10-20kBps...and if they do, then everyone should be facing this issue, isnt it...but that isnt the case...
and the pdf file is about mobile number portability...

Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 15 May 08, 11:25 PM
mpranav's Avatar
Hyperactive Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Mumbai
Age: 18
Posts: 130
mpranav is Mysterious
Default Re: What to do about throttling by an ISP?

View Post
Originally Posted by virtua_pirate
why would they throttle the bandwidth by mere 10-20kBps...and if they do, then everyone should be facing this issue, isnt it...but that isnt the case...
and the pdf file is about mobile number portability...
Yup,IF they did throttle torrents then you wouldn't even get 20KBps speed.
10-20KBps less than HTTP download speed is quite good for torrents.

Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes


Welcome, Unregistered.

  
Search
Advertisement


From FunEnclave
Quick Navigation

All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 07:28 PM.


Style by Safin, exclusive for TechEnclave
Copyright ©2005 - 2008 TechEnclave.com, All Rights Reserved.
Powered by vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0