 | | 
21 Nov 09, 01:37 PM
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 34
| | Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Hello,
I have heard that the latest Ubuntu 9.10 has been found with many bugs, dont no about fedora 12 or Opensuse 11.2 and also Mandriva2010 linux. So plase tell me as i ma a novice and only for some time used Ubuntu 9.04 through Wubi install, and not anyo ther linux distro, which among the four is more stable and easy suited for beginers like me.I have ubuntu 9.04 Cd only, so should I use this and not change to latest 9.10 or should i go for fedora,mandriva or opensuse latest.
Please tell me.
Thanks,
And also please tell me is KDE now stable comapre to GNOMe
Last edited by Shanpav12; 21 Nov 09 at 01:48 PM.
Reason: Post merged automatically to prevent bumping.
| 
21 Nov 09, 03:32 PM
|  | Fanatic Member | | Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Bangalore Age: 24
Posts: 242
| | Re: Whcih is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuseand Fedora Well if you are looking for most stable linux then go for Debian or Gentoo. But Gentoo installation is very time consuming as you have to compile the complete OS on your system...anyways Ubuntu is best for new users and I haven't observed a crash in Ubuntu...also Genome is more stable than KDE...but KDE has got eye candy...I prefer KDE | 
21 Nov 09, 06:31 PM
|  | Junior Member | | Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 41
| | Re: Whcih is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuseand Fedora Use Redhat its one of the stable and widely used linux os.
Debian is the biggest linux distribution .ubuntu Is also good they will be out with bugs.i prefer Redhat i run it on vmware.Normally use it to study shell scripting not a poweruser | 
21 Nov 09, 09:14 PM
|  | Fanatic Member | | Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 172
| | Re: Whcih is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuseand Fedora I have Ubuntu 9.04 and its very stable. Never faced any issues. I have tried Fedora in the past, many times it failed even to install, so never tried it after that.
Always partition the HDD in a way, you can easily change the OS flavor, but never loose your data.
I always keep OS and Data separate, so even if I have reinstall the OS, my data is safe and sound. | 
21 Nov 09, 10:16 PM
|  | Freedom ! | | Join Date: May 2006 Location: /sys/power
Posts: 5,742
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Mandriva 2010 pwns Ubuntu 9.10, theres ext4 issue and other in Ubuntu . Haven't tried SUSE and Fedora latest release yet | 
22 Nov 09, 06:01 PM
|  | Hyperactive Member | | Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Mumbai
Posts: 60
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora For a newbie, definately Linux Mint or Sabayon for what comes out of the box, and how smooth the transition is. It will take some time before you say "oh, my Linux broke, and I don't know what to do!" Sabayon has most of the functionality as Linux Mint, and is a very mature and stable distro, based on Gentoo if I am not mistaken.
As for the more stable of the two, it is Gnome - which can be made to look well too - there are misconceptions that it is a dull and boring DE - case in point, is again, Linux mint. KDE is also great, and a wee bit more user friendly. Have used three of the four distros you listed, and this is where each of them will break:
Ubuntu - the codecs, you cannot play mp3s out of the box, and the interface suffers from strange glitches - not bugs that are predictable, but random glitches that just go a little haywire now and then.
OpenSuse - the package manager is a little buggy, but the one click install is convinient - about half of the time that it actually works. Easier to get codecs installed here - because of a very prominant and easy to follow tutorial, but still does not play anything useful out of the box.
Fedora - Great to start learning some of the advanced stuff right away, but you will have to spend some time with it.
If you want a plain and direct answer, definately go for Linux Mint, you will not be disappointed. It is Ubuntu minus all the quirks and difficulties for noobs (please do not misinterpret the word).
Last edited by Uriel; 22 Nov 09 at 06:46 PM.
| 
22 Nov 09, 07:19 PM
| | Hyperactive Member | | Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 62
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora just make sure to use ext3 filesystem as opposed to ext4 if stability is a concern with which ever distro you use. | 
23 Nov 09, 09:39 AM
|  | Fanatic Member | | Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 179
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Quote:
Originally Posted by Dark Star Mandriva 2010 pwns Ubuntu 9.10, theres ext4 issue and other in Ubuntu . Haven't tried SUSE and Fedora latest release yet  | The ext4 issue has been fixed as it was a critical issue. Not really a filesystem fault, I think it had something to do with applications not using filesystem sync calls appropriately. Fedora has always been a pain for me; while they do ship with latest and greatest software, most packages I've used have been buggy (YMMV).
openSUSE 11.2 looks quite nice, the UI is uniform across GNOME and KDE but I've not used it much.
In terms of stability I think Ubuntu 9.10 should be quite stable, I've been running a system at home without any issues for the past month or so. Quote: |
And also please tell me is KDE now stable comapre to GNOMe
| GNOME is more widely used than KDE I think. I did use KDE for a while, I suppose it is quite stable now. You should try both and decide for yourself. | 
23 Nov 09, 10:12 AM
| | Piled higher&deeper | | Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 160
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora use freebsd and stay stable  (j/k)
try archlinux if you are into learning something about linux innards. | 
23 Nov 09, 10:17 AM
|  | Fanatic Member | | Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 151
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora if your purpose for linux is to use it as some server and need rock solid srability.
I recommend for going for CentOS 5.x it's enterprise level of distro and it's free.
if your purpose if for linux os to use as desktop os then go for Fedora.
Hope that helps | 
23 Nov 09, 12:25 PM
|  | The mad techie! | | Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Pune
Posts: 1,211
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Quote:
Originally Posted by Shanpav12 Hello,
I have heard that the latest Ubuntu 9.10 has been found with many bugs, dont no about fedora 12 or Opensuse 11.2 and also Mandriva2010 linux. So plase tell me as i ma a novice and only for some time used Ubuntu 9.04 through Wubi install, and not anyo ther linux distro, which among the four is more stable and easy suited for beginers like me.I have ubuntu 9.04 Cd only, so should I use this and not change to latest 9.10 or should i go for fedora,mandriva or opensuse latest.
Please tell me.
Thanks,
And also please tell me is KDE now stable comapre to GNOMe |
I would advise you to check out the issues in any of the distros and check if they hamper you. If they don't then you can use them. I am using 9.04 and am quite comfy with it. I hardly change my os every release.
+LT | 
23 Nov 09, 08:15 PM
| | Steroids Member | | Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 474
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Quote:
Originally Posted by Dark Star Mandriva 2010 pwns Ubuntu 9.10, theres ext4 issue and other in Ubuntu . Haven't tried SUSE and Fedora latest release yet  |
and his ubuntu hate continues
Am using 9.10 x86-64 .
yet to face any problems .
and ext4 is fast .
I am getting 1.5 times the HD performance here . | 
24 Nov 09, 09:42 AM
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 18
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora I'm using Fedora 12 and haven't faced any issues so far! I like the rpm based systems more, but that's just me.
If you're looking for stability, go with Debian or Fedora. Just know that Debian has a very long release cycle. Ubuntu is made out of the unstable releases of Debian | 
24 Nov 09, 12:21 PM
| | Steroids Member | | Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 474
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Quote:
Originally Posted by karan812 I'm using Fedora 12 and haven't faced any issues so far! I like the rpm based systems more, but that's just me.
If you're looking for stability, go with Debian or Fedora. Just know that Debian has a very long release cycle. Ubuntu is made out of the unstable releases of Debian |
Yep , and what is fedora based on ?
Fedora has more bleeding edge software than ubuntu . | 
24 Nov 09, 06:37 PM
|  | Explosive Member | | Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Bangalore/Beijing
Posts: 1,558
| | re: Which is more stable Linux OS between Ubuntu,Mandriva,Opensuse and Fedora Quote:
Originally Posted by viridian The ext4 issue has been fixed as it was a critical issue. Not really a filesystem fault, I think it had something to do with applications not using filesystem sync calls appropriately. | The bug is still open..... https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+s...ux/+bug/453579 Quote:
Originally Posted by viridian In terms of stability I think Ubuntu 9.10 should be quite stable, I've been running a system at home without any issues for the past month or so. | 9.04 was rock stable for me, will be removing kubuntu 9.10 this week and installing ubuntu 9.10 Quote:
Originally Posted by viridian GNOME is more widely used than KDE I think. I did use KDE for a while, I suppose it is quite stable now. You should try both and decide for yourself. | GNOME is dead stable hands down  Using KDE 4.3.3 atm still lots of bugs, well i guess bugs are natural as KDE is too much innovative compared to GNOME. You pay some price. |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | | | Search TechEnclave | | | | | | | | |
Have some Fun!
| | | |